Nutter Butter Turkeys | Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies
We’ve transformed our classic peanut butter sandwich cookies into adorable turkeys just in time for Thanksgiving. Each Nutter Butter Turkey features our signature crispy peanut-shaped cookies with real peanut butter filling, decorated with colorful turkey details that make every snack a festive celebration.
These limited-edition Thanksgiving cookies bring joy to your holiday table, lunchboxes, or party platters. Kids and adults alike love the familiar Nutter Butter taste paired with the playful turkey design that captures the spirit of the season.
- Classic Nutter Butter peanut-shaped cookies in festive turkey design
- Real peanut butter filling sandwiched between crispy cookies
- Limited-edition Thanksgiving seasonal treat
- Perfect for holiday parties, lunchboxes, and dessert tables
- Individual cookies great for portion control and sharing
Perfect for Thanksgiving Celebrations & Holiday Gatherings
Nutter Butter Turkeys bring smiles to every Thanksgiving celebration, from classroom parties to family dinners. The turkey-shaped design makes them an instant conversation starter on dessert tables, and the individually portioned cookies are ideal for party favors and treat bags.
Parents love using these festive cookies to make the holiday special for kids without spending hours in the kitchen. Set them out alongside pumpkin pie and apple crisp, or pack them in lunchboxes during November to add a touch of seasonal fun to everyday meals.
Ingredients & Allergen Information
Our Nutter Butter Turkeys contain the same wholesome ingredients found in classic Nutter Butter cookies. Real peanut butter creates the signature filling, while enriched flour and sugar form the crispy cookie shells that sandwich the creamy center.
These cookies contain peanuts and wheat, and are manufactured in a facility that also processes tree nuts, soy, and milk. Always check the package label for the most current ingredient and allergen information, as formulations may be updated.
Serving Ideas & Creative Holiday Uses
Beyond serving nutter butter turkeys straight from the package, creative hosts use them to elevate Thanksgiving dessert presentations. Arrange them on a platter around a centerpiece of fall leaves and mini pumpkins, or stand them upright in cupcake frosting to create edible turkey toppers.
Pairing Suggestions
These turkey cookies pair beautifully with warm apple cider, cold milk, or hot chocolate during chilly November gatherings. Create a dessert board by combining them with chocolate-covered pretzels, caramel corn, and other treats from our seasonal collection for a stunning presentation that requires zero baking.
More Festive Treats From Nutter Butter
What people are saying
Questions About Nutter Butter Turkeys
Nutter Butter Turkeys are a limited-edition seasonal product typically available from late September through November while supplies last. Availability varies by retailer, so we recommend checking stores early in the fall season to ensure you can purchase them for your Thanksgiving celebrations.
Since these are seasonal treats, once they sell out at your local store, they may not be restocked until the following year. Many families buy multiple packages when they first appear to enjoy throughout the entire Thanksgiving season.
No, Nutter Butter Turkeys feature the exact same recipe as our classic Nutter Butter peanut butter sandwich cookies. You’ll enjoy the same crispy peanut-shaped cookies and real peanut butter filling you know and love.
The only difference is the festive turkey design printed on the cookies, which adds holiday charm without changing the flavor or texture. This means fans of original Nutter Butter cookies can enjoy the familiar taste while celebrating Thanksgiving with a seasonal twist.
Nutter Butter Turkeys come in a single resealable package containing multiple cookies, similar to our standard cookie packages. The cookies are not individually wrapped, which makes them convenient for serving at parties or placing directly on dessert tables.
The resealable package helps maintain freshness after opening, so you can enjoy a few cookies at a time throughout the Thanksgiving season without worrying about them going stale. Simply seal the package between servings to keep the remaining cookies crispy.
Absolutely! Nutter butter turkeys work wonderfully as cake toppers, cupcake decorations, or crushed into pie crusts for a peanut butter twist on Thanksgiving desserts. Their sturdy construction means they hold up well when inserted into frosting or arranged on top of cheesecakes.
Many creative bakers also crush these cookies to create peanut butter cookie crumbles for sprinkling over ice cream sundaes or mixing into no-bake dessert bars. The turkey design adds visual interest even when cookies are used as decorative elements rather than standalone treats.
Store your Nutter Butter Turkeys in their original resealable package at room temperature in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight and heat sources. Properly stored cookies typically stay fresh and crispy for several weeks.
Avoid refrigerating the cookies, as moisture can make them lose their signature crunch. If you purchase multiple packages, keep unopened ones sealed until you’re ready to enjoy them, which helps maximize freshness throughout the Thanksgiving season.
No, Nutter Butter Turkeys contain peanuts as a primary ingredient and are not suitable for anyone with peanut allergies. These cookies are manufactured in facilities that also process tree nuts, so cross-contamination is possible.
Always read the ingredient label and allergen warnings on the package before serving to guests, especially at gatherings where children may have food allergies. If you’re hosting someone with peanut allergies, we recommend selecting an alternative treat to ensure everyone can safely enjoy your Thanksgiving celebration.
The exact number of cookies per package varies depending on the package size available at your retailer. Standard packages typically contain enough cookies for multiple servings, making them suitable for family gatherings or classroom parties.
Check the package label at the store for the specific net weight and serving information. This will help you determine how many packages you’ll need based on your guest count and how you plan to serve the cookies during your Thanksgiving celebrations.